John McNulty should be a familiar face for a large portion of the Rutgers Scarlet Knights fanbase. After all, this will be his second stint at the school as offensive coordinator as NJ.com reports his hire on Thursday afternoon.
But, that was a decade ago and that was the beginning of an offensive revolution that has seen spread offenses take over the college football world. He last was seen coaching Rutgers during the 2008 season and since then has moved up to the NFL with various stops as a position coach up until this past season when he was the tight ends coach with the Los Angeles Chargers.
It’s an interesting move for the Rutgers program and a name that many didn’t have in their heads when thinking about where Chris Ash would turn after Jerry Kill decided to call it quits due to health concerns this past month.
But, Ash gets a chance to link to the past and get a coach with some loyalty to the Rutgers program too. At least that has to be the hope, but there are serious questions about just what kind of offense the Scarlet Knights will use under McNulty.
Ash has been adamant that he wants a power spread game in place and has been building recruiting classes in that direction. But, McNulty isn’t a coach well-versed in that world, although he does have some spread ideas from his days in the NFL.
On the one hand, he’s got a bit of spread offense experience after being the quarterback coach for the Tennessee Titans with Marcus Mariota in the fold. On the other hand, he also is well-versed in pro-style offenses and ran that while at Rutgers the last time he was in town and did so in record-breaking fashion.
So, who will the Scarlet Knights be under McNulty?
It’s likely that the answer to the identity of the Scarlet Knights offense rides on the players on the roster and what can be most effective in winning them games. Will it be straight spread or straight pro-style offense? We’re likely to see a mix and a lot of the answer to that mix may come from whom McNulty chooses as quarterback.
No question looms larger than if the prize get of the 2018 recruiting class, quarterback Artur Sitkowski, is ready to go or not.
Rutgers hasn’t found a quarterback that is wholly capable of running a spread attack since Ash arrived and it has stunted the offensive production in a big way. John Lewis had a big struggle as anything but a running quarterback in limited action, but with Giovanni Resicgno graduating there will be a new quarterback in the fold no matter what.
One has to believe that McNulty will know how to maximize a quarterback like the 6-5, 220-pound Sitkowski. He’s well-versed in multiple offensive looks, having run an option offense first in high school and then transitioning to a more spread look after transferring to IMG Academy in Florida prior to his junior season.
Sitkowski comes in as the No. 11 ranked pro-style quarterback in the 247Sports composite rankings, the type of recruit at QB that could transform a program like Rutgers if the projections are correct. But, does that mean Sitkowski is the immediate answer?
It will be interesting because McNulty’s offenses in Piscataway were some of the most explosive in the history of Rutgers football, but they were based solely on a strong run game and a complimentary pass attack out of a pro-style look. Names like quarterback Mike Teel, running back Ray Rice and wide receiver Tim Brown were stars under McNulty’s tutelage back in the day.
What McNulty sees from Sitkowski and the other quarterbacks in the room will likely dictate what his offense is built around this season and going forward. The good news is that this appears to be a fresh start for everyone involved in Rutgers’ offense.